69

18 comments

One man has threatened JKR with ‘you’re next’. Guess what? Not a Twitter violation - but there has since been an outcry and I think that man’s account has finally been suspended.

Also, some people being shocked at this but still defending threats against JKR.

Alarmingly, too many people on Twitter saying ‘well, if he hadn’t written something that upset people, this wouldn’t have happened’. You’re allowed to upset people.

[–] bluestocking 29 points Edited

Alarmingly, too many people on Twitter saying ‘well, if he hadn’t written something that upset people, this wouldn’t have happened’. You’re allowed to upset people.

What's most disturbing is that it's not just religious conservatives saying this kind of thing now. It's also people who like to think of themselves as "left" or "progressive" who also think you shouldn't write things that might hurt someone's feelings. As if free speech is only for sanitized texts or things you agree with.

Scary times we live in...

If I ever write a cautionary tale-esque dystopia book, it'll be about a society where hate is banned.

Only certain people’s feelings. If you’re not a member of the sacred caste or happen to have liked the wrong tweet in 2014, prepare the stake!

It is also laughable that the ‘hurty words are literal violence’ crowd are some of the biggest bullies around.

Yes, good point. Whoever is currently considered the protected, most oppressed group, usually. And someone women never fit that.

I don't think (western Christian) religious conservatives ever supported the fatwa against Rushdie? If anything they'd've been using it to argue about the barbarity and godlessness of Islam or something. The only people who would support murdering an author for blaspheming would have been "cultural relativism" lefties, and at the time it was issued the mainstream of those people, and those commenting in print, could still pass as rational. They hadn't gone off the social media/pomo/critical theory deep end yet.

We weren't talking about support for the fatwa. We were talking about people who believe certain things shouldn't be written or published, because they don't personally like them or find them offensive, whether for religious beliefs or other reasons.

Look at all the attempts to ban books over the years, and the majority of them (though not all) tend to come from those on the right and/or religious conservatives. It's never been limited to one side of the political spectrum though, and there are more people who describe themselves as left or liberal are joining in. They just tend to have different reasons to try to ban books and use different approaches than those on the right.