134

Statement this morning from Josh Moon after the site was abruptly dropped by their host in Russia. It does not bode well for freedom of speech on the Internet, or in general, and will only serve to embolden far more authoritarian regimes. This little bird was the canary in the coal mine and now it's dead.

In my life, there is a family emergency. It has absolutely nothing to do with the forum drama. I cannot and will not elaborate further. There will be a week or more where I am completely unavailable and it is likely the site will go down during this time where I will not be able to bring it up.

I want to appraise our situation frankly.

Domain Registrar: Cloudflare was both our application-level DDoS mitigation and our domain registrar. They have given me a way to transfer my domains to another registrar. I do not know what registrar to send it to because I do not have faith in any company.

DDoS Mitigation: DDoS-Guard will drop us dropped us while I was writing this post. This meme about Russia being a free country is a joke. The US is a free country, but with no stewards to protect it. Without the US, there is no second best. I did not expect Cloudflare to crumple so quickly and I don't have a Plan C for DDoS mitigation.

Resource Allocation: I own IP addresses. Our IP allocation is from APNIC. APNIC is one of the 5 private companies which allocate Internet resources around the world. APNIC happens to be based out of Australia, which recently passed draconian censorship laws. There is an effort to get our RIR to revoke our allocation. This would be unprecedented in the history of the Internet, and considering China is in APNIC's region, an absolutely horrific standard which will echo throughout the upcoming decades. There is a non-zero chance of this happening.

Hosting: We have one host and I am looking at two more. It is likely that the host will give up too. The two hosts confident they can handle the Kiwi Farms are probably wrong. DDoS-Guard was confident they could handle the Kiwi Farms and said "bring it on" for less than 24 hours.

This is an organized attack. There is a coalition of criminals trying to frame the forum for their behavior. These criminals provide opportunities for professional victims to amplify their message. Journalists canonize the crimes as the behavior of the forum itself, which becomes the effective truth for the general public.

This is a machine that was built up formerly against 8chan and activates any time the cathedral wants to test the new fronts of its censorship. It is a massive amalgamation of various interests. I am one person. The financial limitations aren't even the real problem - the problem is, I am powerless alone. There is no amount of money I can throw to convince people to be brave and be free. This is just the reality of our country.

And what this machine will not accept is compromise. If I censored specific kinds of behavior, it would not matter. They don't want a specific thing censored. They want the average person to be able to speak in channels where only specific thoughts are acceptable.

More importantly, they want to make it so that no small organization can host a service which threatens the cathedral. It used to be that one guy with a good idea could open a platform and be a Tom Anderson, Mark Zuckerberg, Tom Fulp, Christopher Poole, or Richard Kyanka. Take note these names are all from 10+ years ago. There are no new groundbreakers online anymore because breaking ground in the new Internet's corporate parking lot is not allowed.

I do not see a situation where the Kiwi Farms is simply allowed to operate. It will either become a fractured shell of itself, like 8chan, or jump between hosts and domain names like Daily Stormer.

Essentially what he's saying is that Xi and Putin alike are cheering this right now. I know I will always remember where I was when the 9/11 of the Internet happened. And once again, I feel like the terrorists have won.

Statement this morning from Josh Moon after the site was abruptly dropped by their host in Russia. It does not bode well for freedom of speech on the Internet, or in general, and will only serve to embolden far more authoritarian regimes. This little bird was the canary in the coal mine and now it's dead. > In my life, there is a family emergency. It has absolutely nothing to do with the forum drama. I cannot and will not elaborate further. There will be a week or more where I am completely unavailable and it is likely the site will go down during this time where I will not be able to bring it up. > I want to appraise our situation frankly. > Domain Registrar: > Cloudflare was both our application-level DDoS mitigation and our domain registrar. They have given me a way to transfer my domains to another registrar. I do not know what registrar to send it to because **I do not have faith in any company.** > DDoS Mitigation: > DDoS-Guard will drop us dropped us while I was writing this post. This meme about Russia being a free country is a joke. **The US is a free country, but with no stewards to protect it. Without the US, there is no second best.** I did not expect Cloudflare to crumple so quickly and I don't have a Plan C for DDoS mitigation. > Resource Allocation: > I own IP addresses. Our IP allocation is from APNIC. APNIC is one of the 5 private companies which allocate Internet resources around the world. APNIC happens to be based out of Australia, which recently passed draconian censorship laws. There is an effort to get our RIR to revoke our allocation. This would be **unprecedented in the history of the Internet,** and considering **China is in APNIC's region, an absolutely horrific standard which will echo throughout the upcoming decades.** There is a non-zero chance of this happening. > Hosting: > We have one host and I am looking at two more. It is likely that the host will give up too. The two hosts confident they can handle the Kiwi Farms are probably wrong. DDoS-Guard was confident they could handle the Kiwi Farms and said "bring it on" for less than 24 hours. > This is an organized attack. There is a coalition of criminals trying to frame the forum for their behavior. These criminals provide opportunities for professional victims to amplify their message. **Journalists canonize the crimes as the behavior of the forum itself, which becomes the effective truth for the general public.** > This is a machine that was built up formerly against 8chan and activates **any time the cathedral wants to test the new fronts of its censorship.** It is a **massive amalgamation of various interests.** I am one person. The financial limitations aren't even the real problem - the problem is, **I am powerless alone.** There is no amount of money I can throw to convince people to be brave and be free. This is just the reality of our country. > **And what this machine will not accept is compromise.** If I censored specific kinds of behavior, it would not matter. They don't want a specific thing censored. **They want the average person to be able to speak in channels where only specific thoughts are acceptable.** > More importantly, **they want to make it so that no small organization can host a service which threatens the cathedral.** It used to be that one guy with a good idea could open a platform and be a Tom Anderson, Mark Zuckerberg, Tom Fulp, Christopher Poole, or Richard Kyanka. Take note these names are all from 10+ years ago. There are no new groundbreakers online anymore because breaking ground in the new Internet's corporate parking lot is not allowed. > **I do not see a situation where the Kiwi Farms is simply allowed to operate.** It will either become a fractured shell of itself, like 8chan, or jump between hosts and domain names like Daily Stormer. Essentially what he's saying is that Xi and Putin alike are cheering this right now. I know I will always remember where I was when the 9/11 of the Internet happened. And once again, I feel like the terrorists have won.

396 comments

Hope not. I've watched a few forum leaders get taken down, but that was research chemical forums and they were moving drugs/talking openly about it. As long as Null has his hands clean he should be good. But the FBI's tactics are dirty, they can hide their discovery tactics at trial so defendants can't form a proper defense. (See: Silk Road leader Ross Ulbricht's trial).

Ross Ulbricht's trial was an absolute farce and affront to democracy and human rights. If it happened in a non-WEstern country it would be considered tyrannical. Imagine serving a double life without parole sentence for running a website that sells - among many innocuous things - a few drugs. You get less for actual murder.

Josh could easily be (falsely) convicted of conspiracy to commit terrorism, murder etc. It doesn't matter that it's not true, a lot of the shit about silkroad wasn't true either.

Glad you agree. Felt so bad for his mother too. She seems like the sweetest lady :\

It's not hard to see why so many other nations hate our guts & cheer our downfall in every comment section on the interwebs. I abhor violence & extremism of all kinds, but I don't blame them one bit. Our leaders are absolute evil. In no universe should hosting/running an internet forum constitute grounds for government surveillance, entrapment/raids, etc. Especially if that site increased the safety of purchasing drugs by reducing violence & overdoses due to adulteration. Chuck Schumer was one of the most vocal critics of Silk Road which told me all I needed to know about him.