WTAF? He did!??!? Who?

Makes me wonder if that TiM was catfishing - got maybe one date w/ him and then nothingburger so he has to make it all up. I bet he blackmailed Phelps.

Yeah, this screams "We never actually dated, and I just hallucinated an entire relationship with him."

[–] OneStarWolf 2 points Edited

That’s what I was thinking. Because there are no paparazzi photos of them together, so it must have maybe been a 1 date thing and Phelps noped out quick when he realized it was a man.