13
FantasyPiranesi | Susanna Clarke
Posted December 23, 2020 by lucrecia in Books

A few people mentioned this on spinster a while back, and I just finished it, so figured I might as well make a thread for anyone who wants to say anything. I daresay there will be spoilers so this is your chance to click away if you haven't read. :)

...

Misc. thoughts:

This was fun! The descriptions of visual layouts, though dramatic and clear, were somewhat wasted on me, as I have no talent for visualising that sort of thing. But I wasn't bored since they're always grounded in the narrator's attitudes to the details, and the underlying ideas are cool. It's a little like reading someone describing the scenery of a dream (I wondered if that inspired her, though I haven't looked yet), or even a videogame (I'd've loved to see Team Ico do a take on the setting!). In terms of other books, it put me in mind of Garth Nix's Old Kingdom, especially eg: the library of the Clayr, combined with The Secret History (Donna Tartt). I feel like this is The Secret History's cheerful cousin, if a book can be such a thing. I think you could have some fun constructing a crossover, anyway...

And the cover is very pretty.

Feel free to share any thoughts!

6 comments

[Deleted]December 24, 2020
heartwitchDecember 24, 2020

Are there any interesting, well-developed female characters? I had a hard time with Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell because it had a such a boys' club atmosphere.

lucrecia [OP]December 24, 2020

Talking about any characters is a bit of a spoiler so I've tagged it. So, there aren't many characters mentioned, and those are mostly male. I would say only the main, male character has any real development, but it's quite a solitary sort of book and characters are closer to plot-devices or mysteries than people (which is not to say they're wooden; they're quite lively, we just don't see them in much detail). There are probably more birds than people in the book. So in terms of representation, I would recommend it for bird-representation or statue-representation but not any variety of positive human representation.

[Deleted]December 24, 2020

I haven't read it but I've been wanting to for a while, I think because I saw someone recommend it on here. I have a hold on the ebook version from my local library but I have to wait 10 weeks 😩 (I've also had this hold for several weeks already...)

ActualWendyDecember 24, 2020

Thanks for this. I'm on the waitlist at the library.