34
ReviewsPlease enjoy this extremely savage recent book review
Posted October 20, 2021 by [Deleted] in Books

NYT: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/15/books/review/look-at-us-tl-toma.html

Archive: https://archive.md/yJFQD

  1. Point: Man writes gross-sounding mediocre novel.
  2. Counterpoint: Women writes delightfully savage review of said novel.

Excerpt: > Martin spends a lot of time imagining the exotic, yet in his view more authentic, lives of the less privileged people around him — his building super, for example, an Estonian immigrant who, Martin observes, carries an “odor of garlic and tobacco,” and the super’s wife, whom Martin imagines to have a “rich woody boscage” of a vagina. These essentialized fantasies are often connected with sex and are, predictably, even more distasteful when the people he’s describing aren’t white — after watching a documentary about Mexican pearl divers, he concludes that their modest shacks were a fair trade for their lovers, “women who took pleasure in the pleasure they could give a man.” Later he fantasizes about being with his own “dusky woman.”

In conclusion: > ...I was mostly too tired to care.

Has anyone read Lydia Kiesling's work? This review made me more interested in reading her debut novel than this dude's book.

47 comments

WhichWitchAmIOctober 18, 2024

I thought at first the question was which deadly sin are you most fond of. Sloth. I enjoy it.

DietCokeAddictOctober 16, 2024

Is there an eighth deadly sin called Doomscrolling, or does that just fall under Sloth?

GenderHereticOctober 16, 2024

It's kind of a combination of all of them.

HanlonsrazorOctober 17, 2024

Probably a heady mix of gluttony and sloth. I wouldn’t call my thriftiness or my career something that’s fueled by greed etc.

kuzcos_poisonOctober 16, 2024

Gluttony and Sloth. I like food and I like lying around lmao.

PatitaGrisOctober 16, 2024

You, me and at least half of the mammals in Earth.

I don't even think those are sins, let alone capital ones. Is the default configuration for living things and nobody can convince me otherwise

velvetpawsBig timeOctober 16, 2024

Well Christianity is a renunciative religion. So I don’t think they would try to convince you that sloth and gluttony aren’t the default configuration, but that they should be overcome.

SpringMaidenOctober 16, 2024

Sure, but with how much they emphasis sin and stuff, it kinda feels more punitive than aspirational sometimes, you know?

EvileineOctober 16, 2024

I'm right there with you!

[Deleted]October 17, 2024

Definitely sloth. I identify as this penguin who doesn’t want to get out of bed

OxyToxinOctober 16, 2024

Definitely Wrath, but my Sloth keeps it submerged so it's fairly inconspicuous.

Re-enacterfOctober 16, 2024

Sloth for sure, but also anemia.

SoftieCactusOctober 16, 2024

Sloth, but also hypothyroidism. 🥴 Lol.

beingOctober 16, 2024

lol this should have been my answer! I wish I had thought of that

Captain_AFABOctober 16, 2024

Wrath, unfortunately. I'd rather be less angry and have other problems instead, but here we are. I'm working on it.

hard_headed_womanOctober 16, 2024(Edited October 16, 2024)

Wrath when I was younger.

Sloth now that I'm older, but I feel like I've earned my sloth, so I don't feel too guilty about it. :)

Metal_detectorOctober 16, 2024(Edited October 16, 2024)

Lust and wrath

velvetpawsBig timeOctober 16, 2024

This is the most masculine answer, but I honestly don’t know what the most feminine answer would be.

Metal_detectorOctober 16, 2024

that’s cuz men aren’t punished for these traits.

TheChaliceIsMightierOctober 16, 2024(Edited October 16, 2024)

Heyyyy twinsies. But my wrath largely went away after I finally got divorced.

Metal_detectorOctober 16, 2024

My wrath has been channeled into looking up articles about men behaving badly in dresses haha

That’s wonderful! I’ve mellowed out as I’ve aged

TheChaliceIsMightierOctober 15, 2024

Lust

TheChaliceIsMightierOctober 16, 2024

Someone else needs to comment lust so I don't feel alone 😂

worried19October 16, 2024

Lust for me, absolutely.

TheChaliceIsMightierOctober 16, 2024

Glad it's not just me. I don't feel I have a lot of vices, but lust is definitely one. A lot of my dumbest decisions are related to that.

Lady_MerlinOctober 15, 2024

Sloth

MafdetOctober 16, 2024

Used to be Lust but with my absolute lack of love life, it's currently Wrath.

stern-as-steelOctober 16, 2024

Definitely Pride. I’m working on it though…

[Deleted]October 15, 2024

I don't consider Pride a sin (unless we are talking about the parade-lol); I consider lack of humility a sin. So I am going with sloth.

TheChaliceIsMightierOctober 15, 2024

Hubris

[Deleted]October 16, 2024

ah yes, good word. More of that than I prefer to see around here, but I suffer from it too. I am suffering from it right now in fact!

ElizabelchOctober 16, 2024

Maybe Pride, but then again I did just wake up from a nap, so maybe Sloth

faerieberryOctober 15, 2024

Sloth lol

AmareldysOctober 16, 2024

Gluttony, sloth and lust

beingOctober 16, 2024

right now I'd say sloth, with a side of gluttony and envy. I'm least guilty of wrath and pride

SpringMaidenOctober 16, 2024

Sloth, or maybe Envy?

Lol, to be honest, aside from Lust and Gluttony, I’m kinda guilty of all of them equally.

EdelgardOctober 16, 2024

From most to least 'guilty':

Pride > Wrath > Sloth > Gluttony > Greed > Envy > Lust.

NotEnoughPagesOctober 16, 2024

Envy.

MandyOctober 16, 2024

Sloth

readfreakOctober 16, 2024

Sloth

pellucidarOctober 16, 2024

Team Sloth!

inTERFerenceOctober 16, 2024

🦥

Hedge_WitcherooOctober 16, 2024

Sloooooth. After that probably lust and wrath.

FernLadyOctober 15, 2024

Pride

EmmaGildedOctober 16, 2024

Sloth.

LobselVithOctober 16, 2024

I guess my homosexuality made me sinner enough so I don't get to be much of a sinner based on the deadly sins! 🤭 If I really had to pick one, maybe that would be pride.

velvetpawsBig timeOctober 16, 2024

Interesting choice given the rest of your answer!