12
QuestionAre there any feminist-friendly fandom spaces or groupchats?
Posted October 20, 2024 by Gray in Women

Does anyone here know of any existing fandom spaces or groupchats that allow open discussion without banning those who question gender ideology? Or at least groups that ban the discussion of politics entirely so that the TRA stuff isn’t always in our faces?

Fanfiction has been a long-time hobby of mine, but there’s hardly any fandom spaces left anymore that encourage critical thinking and allow for freedom to disagree on issues relating to gender/TRA stuff. I heard that there may be some gender-critical/radfem fanfiction discord servers or other groups out there, so I was wondering if I could get an invite over DM if anyone knows of any?

If there’s no active groups like this out there, I’ve been considering trying to find enough others here that would be interested in creating a fanfiction focused group, especially for the Harry Potter fandom, since I have the impression that I’m not the only one here who’s been looking for this type of space that doesn’t censor feminist opinions or isn’t filled with TRAs and TIPs.

16 comments

Hedge_WitcherooOctober 20, 2024

I didn't have one, but would absolutely be down to joining one! I used to be in a Harry Potter fangroup when I was young lol

Discord servers are pretty easy to set up. I just made a spirituality and ancient period/SCA study women's group. They're also free

Gray [OP]October 21, 2024

I’ll send you a DM so that we can chat about this more! :) If we can find a handful of others here wanting to join, I’d be happy to get a discord server started for us!

spinningintellectOctober 21, 2024

Oh my god, please DM me about this!

FlowerMoonBunnyKissOctober 21, 2024

I'm interested!

SunlightOctober 21, 2024

I haven't been able to find any, but I'd love to join one. It's a drain being active in fandom spaces, knowing most of them would turn on me at the drop of a hat for not worshipping the T.

Gray [OP]October 21, 2024

I’ll send you a DM! :)

Luna_LovegoodOctober 21, 2024

You rang? ;)

Gray [OP]October 21, 2024

Hi! :) I love your username! If you know of any HP fandom spaces for feminists, I would love to join them!

DerpinaOctober 21, 2024

I dont write HP FF (to be correct, I havent written anything in like 3 years) but sign me up for any fandom group anywhere!

gentooOctober 21, 2024

Hopping in to say that some folks from this site set up a Livejournal meme-style anonymous fandom space (although we mostly just complain about real life and talk about soup these days). It's slow and very chill, but if that's anyone's cup of tea, I'm happy to provide details on how to access it in a DM.

MandyOctober 21, 2024

I would be interest in joining both of these.

Gray [OP]October 21, 2024

Hi! :) Is it okay if I send you a DM?

Gray [OP]October 21, 2024

If I do create a server or other sort of group for fanfiction, does anyone here have any suggestions for what security measures should be set in place to protect the community from trolls and people joining in bad faith?

Would anyone here be interested in helping me with either building and designing the space, and/or helping moderate it? If we can get a trusted group of at least five to ten of us willing to help with moderating or screening members, I think building up a fandom community for feminists/gender-criticals could become feasible and easy to manage.

Iota_AurigaeNovember 3, 2024

I’m late, but I moderate a server that has a verification system set up. New users fill out a form which mods look over to determine whether or not they’ll be given full access to the server. Some TRAs might try to get in, but if they try to fake being a radfem, they’ll usually fill out the form with “information” about radical feminism that they heard from other TRAs - so it’s easy to spot. There may also be trolls who spam “I hate [insert slur here]” in all of the response fields.

CalaisOctober 21, 2024

'No hate' is a good old way. 'Hate' in this case does not refer to vauge feelings of negativity about whomever is currently en vouge as a victim.

It refers to needlessly criticising, or heaping negativity upon something that someone else enjoys, be it real-world opinions, people's sex, or a certain character/ship that people don't like.

This also helps keep a good atmosphere. For example, while I am deeply unhappy with trans people invading my spaces, I would prefer to rant about them to a friend. In fandom spaces, mild, civil criticism could be fine, but ranting about them would incur negative energy, and place the focus on politics rather than fandom.

Gray [OP]October 24, 2024

I fully agree! This is how I would want for the group to be run tbh, since I think freedom for women to have discussions civilly and express differing opinions is important, but there’s ways to express these opinions without hate or judgement, so I wouldn’t want a negative atmosphere to be created where members can’t put aside their politics and let others enjoy fandom in peace. Most fandom spaces go by rules like “ship and let ship” or I think that would be a good rule to implement as well.