I couldn’t find anything in the article that actually supported the headline. The only findings discussed in the article are these:
Children who exercise are less likely to be hyperactive and have behavioral problems such as loss of temper, fighting, lying and stealing
Higher levels of moderate or intense physical activity had a small but detectable association with decreases in depressive symptoms and emotional difficulties
Researchers said the findings suggest regular moderate and intense physical activity may have a small protective influence on mental health in early adolescence.
I believe all of those findings to be true, and that exercise can help to relieve some of the symptoms of ADHD, but that does not support the statement that exercise “slashes…risk of ADHD”. In fact, the article does not indicate that the researchers made ANY mention of ADHD, let alone commented on the “risk factor” of ADHD. If your headline states that the risk factor was “slashed”, wouldn’t you want to provide the supporting metric, or any evidence of it at all?
Every reference to ADHD in the article pertains to the increase in Adderall diagnoses/prescriptions, and refers to it as a “behavioral issue”, when it is in fact a neurological disorder that may or may not result in behavioral issues.
It seems to me that the author incorrectly extrapolated the actual findings to support her own pre-existing beliefs about ADHD and medications, and presented her opinion as fact. Poorly written article all around.
Welcome to /o/STEM! This circle is dedicated to science, technology, engineering, maths, and medicine, where you can discuss all things STEM, seek career advice, share learning resources, and pose “ask an expert” questions to the Ovarit STEM community.
Please provide a descriptive title for your posts and add a flair that best describes your post topic. We encourage posters to add links to relevant articles or research papers in their posts and comments.
Since our focus is on STEM, posts should not be focused on politics, ethics, or philosophy. Any discussion on popular science or medicine (to include COVID-19) must be based on scientific principles and research.
This is also not the place to discuss diet, lifestyle, alternative medicine, or psychology. For these topics please check out o/women which is a general discussion circle and o/womenshealthlounge which is a support sub for health issues.
I couldn’t find anything in the article that actually supported the headline. The only findings discussed in the article are these:
I believe all of those findings to be true, and that exercise can help to relieve some of the symptoms of ADHD, but that does not support the statement that exercise “slashes…risk of ADHD”. In fact, the article does not indicate that the researchers made ANY mention of ADHD, let alone commented on the “risk factor” of ADHD. If your headline states that the risk factor was “slashed”, wouldn’t you want to provide the supporting metric, or any evidence of it at all?
Every reference to ADHD in the article pertains to the increase in Adderall diagnoses/prescriptions, and refers to it as a “behavioral issue”, when it is in fact a neurological disorder that may or may not result in behavioral issues.
It seems to me that the author incorrectly extrapolated the actual findings to support her own pre-existing beliefs about ADHD and medications, and presented her opinion as fact. Poorly written article all around.
I agree. Well said.