13
QuestionAnyone in the mental health or medical field?
Posted May 20, 2023 by [Deleted] in GenderCritical

(My major was Psychology, but I didn’t work with humans.)

I’m wondering what others in these fields think about all the transing going on?

Are they aware and allude to it being lucrative, or do they think they’re really doing the right thing? Have you heard anyone mention the poor quality research and the significant design flaws? Or the results of this big experiment in transing problems away?

It seems to me that trans is about one to three things, 1. escapism from trauma, 2. sexual fetishizing, 3. social mirroring (indoctrination)/attention seeking behavior.

Any of these to the degree that someone is rearranging their entire life and creating a brand new identity is pretty pathological in severity, no?

Furthermore, bringing it to such extreme heights as body modification?

How can anyone think that this is healthy behavior to encourage, or a solution to any of the underlying root causes?

We’ve all seen the papers on high prevalence of autism, sexual assault, and other poor mental health.

These things often happen before any child could have ever known about any of the endless gender ideology. It’s not the chicken or the egg, we already know and have concluded that it’s the egg. No one can be transphobic to them before they’re transphobic. Which is what their high suicide rate is always blamed on.

41% of the population of transed people committing suicide doesn’t sound like transing is the solution???

And we see this end result so often.

Anecdotally speaking, almost to a fault, every TIF or Non-binary female posts “woe is me” material that’s obviously not what MI managed people post. “You’ll miss me when I’m gone”, “I’m all alone”, etc.

Then with TIMs and non-binary males, you see mentally unbalanced aggression and sexual excesses.

Not healthy sexual exploration in private, but Only Fans level selfies all over the place in public, and incredibly passive aggressive, and physically violent statements/memes. “The only good TERF is a dead TERF.” “Transphobes are just angry bc I stole their man.” Anarchy idiocy that no mature, logical person espouses as reality. Etc.

All of them seem to have fixations on anime, video games, etc. Obsessions.

And this is AFTER they’ve transed.

It’s really hard to believe that anyone in these fields can really not be aware of this, and not conclude that this is a failed experiment in alternative treatment?

33 comments

firebirdOctober 17, 2022

Ah yes, the two genders: normal person and weirdo who refuses to hold the door open for others.

[Deleted]October 17, 2022

Right like what kind of goblin just lets the door fall on someone!

Roe_More_BullOctober 18, 2022

Unfortunately my girlfriend and I have not figured out how to resolve the door and jar issues without one of us transitioning or inviting a man to come live with us. We’ve just grown accustomed to living in a house full of doors and jars that we simply cannot open.

estinaOctober 17, 2022

Ugh this poor girl (sounds like written by 15 year old if I had to guess)

PtarmagantOctober 17, 2022

Back when she was a 'girl', did she just swan through doors, letting them slam on the person behind her? Nice.

Sailor_ParadiseOctober 18, 2022

That's funny because I hold the door whenever I can. How is that a gender specific thing especially in current day

[Deleted]October 18, 2022

Same, I’ve been doing that for decades.

legopantsOctober 17, 2022

This is so pathetic. How can not one of them see how regressive and pointless this all is.

SakuraBlossomstransheight 7'3"October 18, 2022(Edited October 18, 2022)

"Things that give me euphoria"

  1. Wearing clothes that women commonly wear

  2. Breast binding

  3. Having basic manners

  4. Getting old enough to open jars without Mommy's help

I don't understand the trans movement at all.

SpatOutTheKoolaidOctober 18, 2022

Wow. Sounds like someone needs a life.

AlwaysOrdduOctober 17, 2022

Guess it's back to letting doors slam on people for me! I'll be over here throwing away all my men's hoodies and quietly starving to death as I stare down the tantalizing foods hopelessly encased in glass prisons.

catspyjamas1October 17, 2022

Serious question : is it uncommon to hold doors in the US? People would think you are a jerk if you slammed the door in their face in Germany, regardless of your gender.

FeministunderyrbedOctober 17, 2022

There’s a difference between holding the door behind you and standing to the side letting somebody else go through ahead of you. Most people do the former but the latter is supposed to be reserved for “gentlemen” as a courtesy to “ladies”—and for me because I just don’t care.

OwnLyingEyesOctober 17, 2022

Woman here who holds doors open for people all the time, especially when their hands are full, and the best brute force jar-opener I ever met was a tiny Thai woman who basically had vices for hands (I have my techniques, though).

GenderHereticOctober 17, 2022

Even though men have much greater grip strength than women, women are conditioned to just give up and not bother finding out their own strength levels at all. She really thinks it's her trans identity and magic metamorphosis potion that did it.

Iota_AurigaeOctober 17, 2022

I held a door open for someone earlier, guess I must be a man!

[Deleted]October 17, 2022

Stab the lid. It's the tricky cava bottles that cause me gyp. Thank God for tea towels and a British determination to drink.

AngryPotatoOctober 17, 2022

I’ve always been really good at opening jars that other people can’t. It’s one of my few skills. Not any less a woman though.

catspyjamas1October 17, 2022

We don't know that yet. Do you regularly attend sleepovers where you have pillow fights with other girls? Does math give you a headache? Do you cry for at least two hours a day and/or experience extreme emotions most of the time? If the answer to any of these questions is "no", it is my duty, nay, pleasure, to inform you that you in all likelihood are actually a man.

AngryPotatoOctober 17, 2022

Damn, it’s a no to all of those. Guess I’m ultra male then.

[Deleted]October 17, 2022(Edited October 17, 2022)

Image transcription: r/egg_irl

Galaxy brain meme:

1st panel: wearing boy clothes

2nd panel: wearing binder

3rd panel: holding doors open

4th and last panel: getting that damn glass jar open when no one else managed to

Caption: things that give me euphoria

[Deleted]October 17, 2022

Joint pain has made it hard for me to open jars in recent years. But you know what works? Hot water and a fluffy towel. That combo has never yet failed me even with my abysmal grip strength. But if it ever does, I guess transitioning might be on the table. Maybe. (I kid).

FeministunderyrbedOctober 17, 2022(Edited October 17, 2022)

I live alone. There is no backup. I have no particular grip strength but rubber dishwashing gloves are my secret weapon—it’s important for everything to be dry. Really stubborn jars might have to get the edge of the lid tapped on the counter to make a dent and break the seal. Being my own man, Part 38,792.

I also hold doors all the time. It’s just basic decency. Or me totally failing to girl.

friedparataOctober 17, 2022

when I can't open jars, it's always another woman that opens it for me. not a man

spinningintellectOctober 17, 2022

Get a cork screw. Use it to puncture lid. Tada, lid no longer difficult to open.

RedmageOctober 17, 2022

I have joint pain similar to arthritis and I can open jars. It's just a scrap of rubber, or even a dish cloth.

VestalVirginOctober 17, 2022(Edited October 17, 2022)

One of those things is not like the other. Or, well, two.

Holding doors open is just polite. Normal people without gender delusions do it all the time.

Being able to open jars is just great in and of itself. No gender delusions required - I certainly wouldn't complain about feeling "unfeminine" if I was great at opening jars. (I am not, though. It sucks. And me being disappointed that I can't eat whatever is in that jar I couldn't open is not any indication of genderfeelz, thank you very much.)

OwnLyingEyesOctober 17, 2022

If you can break the seal, the lid twists off way easier; just the tip of a knife or a bottle opener inserted up the side of the lid and pry juuuuuust enough to hear it pop/hiss and you should be good to go.

Enjoy your jar contents :)

catspyjamas1October 17, 2022

While I do that while others are watching, what I do when it's just me is pretend I'm an angry male gorilla and just bang it around, while screeching. Sometimes I beat my chest and then take an angry nap.

TwoXChromosomesOctober 17, 2022

I came here to say this exact thing. No need to brute force your way into a jar if you just use your brain.

proudcatladysubtle standoffishnessOctober 17, 2022

Take a shot every time you’re on Ovarit and someone mentions this trick

OwnLyingEyesOctober 17, 2022

Ha, it's an oldie but a goodie

AmareldysOctober 17, 2022

The trick is to apply gentle pressure