22
QuestionWhy Mastectomies after Puberty Blockers?
Posted December 13, 2024 by Odo in GenderCritical

Genuine question. I thought the whole point of puberty blockers, particuarly for girls, was to prevent the development of secondary sex characteristics like developed breasts. In Clementine Breen's case and elsewhere, I keep seeing girls put on puberty blockers at a young age, I'm guessing Tanner 2, but then they get mastectomies anyway. Obviously, if the PBs are administered later and/or the girl started going through puberty earlier, I understand (within the fucked up "cure the body" rationale). But it seems like a common protocol.

Doesn't this show that puberty blockers are useless, at least for girls, if mastectomies are going to happen all the same?

Or is this also something about needing puberty blockers so that cross sex horomones can take effect? Still. I don't get the puberty blocker when young + mastectomy combination. Would very much like to hear an informed explanation. Thx

23 comments

WatcherattheGatesNovember 25, 2024

ONLY IF THE PLANE WAS ON FIRE AND GOING DOWN.

toyotaNovember 26, 2024

Even then I would have my hesitations.

JernsaxaNovember 26, 2024

This and this!

RikkiTikkiTaviNovember 26, 2024

I was genuinely seeking this option in the choices as well.

ProginoskaNovember 25, 2024

I mistakenly got on the plane with snakes in.

DietCokeAddictNovember 26, 2024(Edited November 26, 2024)

Other: I thought it would be really really fun. It was!

Carrots90November 27, 2024

Published BMJ study showing NO difference in deaths / injuries when jumping from airplane with vs without parachute

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30545967/

Keep in mind when reading TRAs studies

SoftieCactusNovember 25, 2024

None of these. I'm happy down on earth!

HoneycreeperBird LesbianNovember 26, 2024

Same. Wouldn’t ever sky dive or deep diving either. I like my feet on earth thanks!

oatmealahhhh my oats!November 26, 2024

Damn Im usually very into risk and adrenaline even participating in some extreme sports but skydiving is... maybe not for me

MandyNovember 26, 2024

Ten million dollars.

RegularFeministNovember 26, 2024(Edited November 26, 2024)

Omg, sad story of my life. I am short and was always thin. I wanted to give myself a present of a parachute jumping for my 18th birthday. Asked my friends to give me money for that. Turned out my weight was not sufficient - you need to be 50 kg at least (in my country), I was around 45. My weight didn't change until I started doing sport and now with gained muscles I have 51-52 kg. But guess what? By now I have heard too many stories of people breaking legs while jumping with a parachute and now I just don't want to. I have always liked being scared in a safe way (horror movies, rollercoaster), but seems that parachute jumping is not that safe.

kuzcos_poisonNovember 26, 2024

I've done it! Tandem, obviously. Brilliant fun. Unless you take it up as a hobby, it's a pretty safe experience. Statistically you're more likely to die driving a car.

EvileineNovember 26, 2024

I'm really just an unusually tall hobbit, and would prefer to keep my toes on the earth where they belong.

faerieberryNovember 25, 2024

Honestly….. none of these? Personally I’m terrified of heights, don’t think anything could ever convince me to go skydiving LOL

Maybe a billion dollars, but that’s about it 😂

FeministunderyrbedNovember 26, 2024

I’d love to go hang gliding and I’m intrigued by bungee jumping, but I’m not interested in totally untethered freefall.

scriptcroneNovember 25, 2024

Bailey's Irish Cream, probably.

velvetpawsBig timeNovember 25, 2024

I think that’s probably closest to answer #1?

scriptcroneNovember 26, 2024

Vote entered, because you're probably right.

Elle_x_ohNovember 25, 2024(Edited November 25, 2024)

Jumping out of a plane (tandem skydive) had fascinated me since lying on the trampoline when my kids were little and watching paras jump out of small planes above us. I was 35ish. Always talked about it. Knew I'd do it...one day. My daughter presented me with the jump for my 50th birthday. No qualms, no "uh...oh...um", not even any nerves. Rolled out of the plane at 8 thousand feet over the Sunshine Coast in Australia.

Tick!

Edit....I got to know a guy who sky-dived (dove? lol) many times. His girlfriend had died jumping. And even that didn't put me off :)

SatanicPanicNovember 26, 2024

Nothing short of an absolute emergency.

broccolipathsofgloryNovember 26, 2024

Other: it's something I've always wanted to do and I'd love to try it.

PiquedInterestNovember 25, 2024

If I got to a point someday where I was no longer scared of heights, then I would consider skydiving to prove to myself that I really had overcame my fear. I'd be more likely to try to do the thing where you're on a kite being pulled by a boat, though. That looks like a better thrill/terror balance 😂