84

I'm tired of trans people saying that there is a "trans genocide" going on. I don't understand how it is a genocide while I get attacked online when I criticise trans people? It is not a genocide when a mentally ill American man in a dress can't enter women's restrooms or their cult can't groom kids. As someone whose ancestors escaped from an actual genocide, the lunacy pisses me off a lot. Most of those people are American and live in the USA, hence extremely privileged in life. They want to be oppressed so much, the trans cult is built on oppression fetish. I'm a "bigot" when say that there's no "trans genocide" or "trans" kids don't exist. I'm so angry at privileged Americans thinking that they are targeted in a "genocide".

I'm tired of trans people saying that there is a "trans genocide" going on. I don't understand how it is a genocide while I get attacked online when I criticise trans people? It is not a genocide when a mentally ill American man in a dress can't enter women's restrooms or their cult can't groom kids. As someone whose ancestors escaped from an actual genocide, the lunacy pisses me off a lot. Most of those people are American and live in the USA, hence extremely privileged in life. They **want to be oppressed** so much, the trans cult is built on oppression fetish. I'm a "bigot" when say that there's no "trans genocide" or "trans" kids don't exist. I'm so angry at privileged Americans thinking that they are targeted in a "genocide".

35 comments

TRAs don’t actually know what a genocide is or else they would be throwing the word around so lightly. Do some research TRAs.

TRAs would be nothing if not extremely careless and sloppy with their asinine comparisons.

As the descendant of Holocaust survivors, I RAGE when these assholes compare the trans experience to "genocide". It's not fucking "genocide" when people don't give you everything you want all the time

[–] VestalVirgin 18 points Edited

Yeah.

Plus, if anyone is committing genocide, it's the TRAs. They're the ones sterilizing children.

THIS! And it doesn't help that most of the kids gettting sterilized and castrated are gay and/or autistic. The medical industry found a way to sterilize and castrate the mentally ill and homosexuals and sell it as a boon to civil rights.

And in Canada, indigenous children are over-represented in the trans population.

All their crying about a supposed “trans genocide” just obscures the fact that gay, lesbian and GNC kids are being targeted, mutilated and sterilized. If anyone is a victim of genocide it is the children targeted by male fetishists to validate their peepee feels.

[–] VestalVirgin 13 points Edited

Exactly. There's a genocide, achieved through sterilization of homosexual and autistic teenagers, and it is driven by TRAs.

The TRA movement is likely the biggest attempt to erase the genes of homosexuals ever since the nazis. (And, let's be honest there, probably more efficient at doing it than the nazis ever were. The nazis imprisoned the homosexuals they could identify, and at the time, most probably weren't outed. The TRAs use an ideology that is bound to mostly appeal to homosexual teenagers with internalized homophobia to set those children on the path to sterilization, all without ever requiring their victims to be outed, or even have any sexual desire, yet. Hitler would never have been able to find out which little girls preferred toy soldiers over dolls to then murder them in case they turn out to be lesbians.TRAs target gender-non-conforming children who never had any sexual thought yet for sterilization, with no problem whatsoever.)

Thinking about it, it's so extremely evil.

If you had told me twenty years or so ago, that a movement would arise of adults telling children "If you have this and that trait (describing traits that are common in homosexual and autistic children), then you ought to sterilize yourself!" ... and that this would be successful ... I would never have believed it.

But that's exactly what's happening.

It's kinda like a horror movie. A government being open about sterilizing people would be in the dystopia genre, but there's something extra creepy about brainwashing that drives children to actively ask to be sterilized.

There's something extra creepy about brainwashing that drives children to actively ask to be threaten to commit suicide if they're not sterilized.

The WW2 jews, uighur muslims, and 1915 Armenians would like a word with TRAs.

[–] GrimaceGravis 0 points Edited

The Ixil Mayans of 1982 and the Tutsi of of 1994 would like to have a word as well.

[–] Califasauros 10 points Edited

"They want to be oppressed" (or, at least seen to be oppressed).

I wonder...prominent female-identifying male Andrea Long Chu once wrote that the essence of being female was "an open mouth, blank, blank eyes, and an expectant asshole." He also wrote that being female meant being a hole waiting to be filled by male desire (I paraphrase here, but you get the picture). Another prominent female-idrntifuing male Grace Lavery wrote at one point that being abused sexually, violently by men was thrilling to him (again, I paraphrase). He also seemed to imply that feeling pain...being a victim was the primal essence of being a woman.

I wonder...perhaps the false victimhood narrative surrounding trans-identifying people...that they're the most victimey victims of all victims...has not been created to just stop critics from analyzing, mocking, parodying gender identity ideology...perhaps it was created because influential autogynephilic female-identifying males within the trans movement get off on imagining themselves AS society's victims.

Is it possible that this victimhood narrative dragged out at every possible moment is part of their fetish...part of their paraphilia?

[–] BigMeanie 8 points Edited

Is it possible that this victimhood narrative dragged out at every possible moment is part of their fetish...part of their paraphilia?

I honestly think this is why the “I stealth/rape drunk men for my own safety” claim is so common. They KNOW raping agro drunk guys seems to be the ONLY path to experiencing the violence they claim is so frequently inflicted upon them.

I just don’t know if it’s activists pushing the “you MUST rape for your own safety” narrative in a bid to acquire some murder victims for the cause or if it’s the individual rapist’s own desire/fetish to experience violence in ways that go beyond the horrors of Netflix specials and stickers defining the word “woman”.

When I first heard about trans people (trans women especially) I couldn't figure out why someone would want to transition. The way I made it make sense in my head that it was a sort of humiliation fetish, that they think being a woman is degrading and they want to be degraded. Not being a victim goes against the whole humiliation fetish they have going on, so yes I agree with you, I think they get off on the whole victimhood thing. But its so weird how they talk about it, like they are very....triumphant about the whole victim thing like why are you like this.

I mean it's not as if Putin isn't making a concerted effort at killing Ukranians or anything...eyeroll

Of course, people who are actually suffering at the hands of tyrants (or have suffered in the past) apparently aren't worthy of note to TRAs because it's not about them.

[–] Riothamus scrote 7 points Edited

They're the only "oppressed" people who threaten suicide because their "oppressors" have no interest in fucking them.

This attitude is so repugnant to anyone who has actually studied genocide. TIMs treat this the same way they treat womanhood. They borrow the suffering of others and wear it as a costume. It's sick.

There is no trans genocide, and in the US and the UK, say, the rates at which transgender people are killed are lower than the rates at which others are killed, and in most cases where the victim of murder was transgender the reason for the murder was the kind that is common in all murders. In other words, that a transgender person is murdered does not necessarily mean that this person was killed for being transgender.

The way statistics is used by the TRAs really should get much more objective attention. Here are a few sources which discuss actual statistics on trans homicide rates:

https://archive.ph/Iv1QI (On UK rates for 2018) https://kareningalasmith.com/2021/04/21/counting-dead-trans-people/ (very good on the UK by Karen Ingala Smith; her site on femicide is important ) https://quillette.com/2019/12/07/are-we-in-the-midst-of-a-transgender-murder-epidemic/ (US data) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5551594/ (a properly done study about US rates 2010-2014, with one of the authors being a trans person)

The suicide risk for young people who believe that they might be trans is also usually not discussed on the basis of good data. The best study I have seen on that is this one, for UK data: Biggs, M. Suicide by Clinic-Referred Transgender Adolescents in the United Kingdom. Arch Sex Behav 51, 685–690 (2022). It shows that the suicide rate for transgender adolescents is 5.5 times higher than for adolescents in general. Suicides by adolescents overall are quite rare, so this is based on four suicides among 15,000 patients the Tavistock gender clinic served between 2010 and 2020, including those patients who were still on the waiting list.

So the transgender adolescent suicide rate is higher than the rate among same age adolescents in general, but it's not one half of all transgender adolescents or 41% of them and so on, and as the study I write about here notes:

The higher risk could have various causes: gender dysphoria, accompanying psychological conditions, and ensuing social disadvantages such as bullying. Studies of young people referred to the GIDS in 2012 and 2015 found a high prevalence of eating disorders, depression, and autism spectrum conditions (ASC) (Holt et al., 2016; Morandini et al., 2021)—all known to increase the probability of suicide (Simon & VonKorff, 1998; Smith et al., 2018).

Eating disorders and depression could be consequences of transgender identity and its ensuing social repercussions, but this is implausible for ASC insofar as it originates in genes or the prenatal environment. From a sample of over 700 referrals to the GIDS in 2012 and 2015, 14–15% were diagnosed with ASC (Morandini et al., 2021). This compared to 0.8–1.1% of students in England (Department for Education, 2012, 2015).

Their weird logic is you are ‘denying their existence’ if you don’t call them a woman and therefore killing them?

I think the "logic" is that trans people commit suicide at much higher rates than the average, and they also suffer from higher rates of violence and murder. Neither of these claims has much good evidence. They believe that if you contribute in any way to a trans person feeling bad or making others question the validity of the trans movement, you are directly responsible for these deaths. They call this "genocide." It's offensive and preposterous, but it seems to work because people don't think critically and are easily swayed by appeals to emotion.

[–] bellatrixbells BoobatrixRex 2 points

And even then, why do they commit suicide so much? Is it because society is tRanSpHoBiC or is it because instead of addressing the cause of their dysphoria/dysmorphia healthcare professionals feed the "wrong body" narrative and try to Frankenstein them into something else, while there's a massive cult following insisting that everybody wants them dead?

No one ever seems to connect the trans suicide "epidemic" with the comorbidity of trans with mental health issues. I'm curious to see how affirmative care has affected the mental health care of TIPs.

If the trans suicide rate was what has been claimed the number of suicides would be front page news, every day. Its BS. Also there would be hardly any trans people left in the US, at least.

Sure I'd love to "kill" their delusions and mental health disorders and fetishes. But kill them? Nah just leave us the fuck alone.

Yeh for sure, just their bizarre logic haha that ‘denying existence = kill’

[–] bellatrixbells BoobatrixRex 2 points

They are ignorant idiots. Jesus, yesterday I tried reading something about Josef Mengele and I couldn't even finish it because I was becoming distressed at the litany of horrors.

To think that these assholes are claiming genocide because doctors won't experiment on them and won't give them wrong sex hormones, at least not for free, and because they can't fuck the people they want regardless of what the people in question feel ... It's... How privileged can you be in life?

Load more (5 comments)