You are viewing a single comment thread. Show all comments.

pakilezApril 7, 2022

One comment: > This review leaves me with a lot of questions about this doc, first and foremost what the filmmakers’ angle is. Is this a criticism of hormonal birth control from a woo woo “natural womanhood” perspective? A criticism of pharmaceutical companies? Far right natalist ideology masquerading as feminism?

Guess I’m far right now

SecondSkinApril 7, 2022(Edited April 7, 2022)

I breastfed twins for 3 years, so I’ve spent plenty time in what they’d likely term woo woo natural womanhood circles. And while I’ve met women that would avoid hbc themselves, because of their bodies reactions, none would ever ban it.

Maybe there’s a uk/us divide in those circles, same as there definitely is in home ed circles (here it mostly seems ex teachers and social workers, whose own kids have some form of nuerodevelopmental disability and schools refuse to accommodate them, or those who realise educating their kids while they learn along side them on their farm or their art studio, works better for them. And home Ed here is heavily based around home Ed meet ups, shared Labour of mums taking the lead on different classes, and the kids -outside of the ones struggling with disability- seem to have better social skills/take exams early and do better etc US seems to be kids taught religious classes and not socialised with other kids. And unprepared for uni. Generally speaking)

goodyusernameApril 7, 2022(Edited April 7, 2022)

What you describe is very similar to the homeschooling circles I'm familiar with in my region of the US. I think it's been growing less dominated by religiously-centered folk for a while.

SecondSkinApril 7, 2022

Yeah, I meant it very generally, hence that disclaimer. But it’s a general description I’ve seen here from women in the US, with critiques of it. And that’s just not what I’ve seen from the home Ed landscape here at all.

jeannedeauxApril 7, 2022

No, we've got a pretty good secular homeschool community in the United States. Two groups of people originally got into it: very conservative Christians, and... hippies.

Yep.

John Holt is an interesting read. He was one of the early influencers of secular HSers.

sylviasmushroomsApril 7, 2022(Edited April 7, 2022)

Can confirm; I’m in my 30s and when I was being homeschooled it was a choice between hyper Christian people who thought dinosaur bones were a trick placed there by the devil, or antivaxxer hippies who wouldn’t let their kids go to the mall because of the “chemicals.”